James Sanders tells a story about a customer at his Beverly barbecue counter who came all the way from Sweden. Sanders said he gave the man something for free just for saying where he was from. He told the story to the Hyde Park Herald while talking about his next restaurant, which is going into 5311 S. Lake Park Ave.
In the same interview, Sanders said one reason he chose Hyde Park is that the neighborhood has gone more than a dozen years without a barbecue restaurant. Longtime residents may remember Ribs 'n' Bibs at 5300 S. Dorchester Ave. The Chicago Maroon reported that it closed in May 2014.
That gap is now closing twice in one season, and the two new places are built for different parts of the day. One is a weekday lunch counter inside a university food hall that keeps academic-calendar hours. The other is a sit-down room with a big bar, built for evenings, happy hour and the game on TV. Together they give the neighborhood barbecue at noon and barbecue at 9 p.m.
The First Arrival Came Through a Dining Hall
Little Betty Smokehouse is chef Dominique Leach's campus offshoot of Lexington Betty Smokehouse, the restaurant she and her wife Tanisha run in Pullman. It officially opened in late September inside Hutchinson Commons at the University of Chicago, according to FoodService Director. It is the brand's first expansion in five years. UChicago Dining lists Hutchinson Commons inside the Reynolds Club at 5706 S. University Ave.
Neighbors don't need a student ID to eat there. The food hall serves students, faculty and the public. WTTW pointed out that this means South Siders near Hyde Park no longer have to go to Pullman for Leach's brisket.
The setup is not like the Pullman restaurant. Orders go through a kiosk, with pickup handled through Grubhub instead of a cashier. Leach told FoodService Director that she sees this as one less role to staff. There is no smoker on campus either. Leach chose to keep cooking on her J&R smoker in Pullman, and smoked meat comes over every day. She described Pullman as moving "more and more towards" being a commissary kitchen.
The menu is built for speed:
- Three proteins. Pulled pork, pulled chicken and brisket go on fries, nachos, mac and cheese or a salad, into tacos or a sandwich, or come on their own with a side such as coleslaw or baked beans.
- Barbecue tacos. Smoked meat with barbecue sauce, tomatillo salsa, pickled red onions, cotija and cilantro on a corn tortilla. Leach told FoodService Director the tacos honor the Mexican vendor that held the spot for years before her.
- Betty's Beef. An Italian beef made with chopped brisket instead of shaved beef, plus American cheese and giardiniera, dipped in au jus and served with barbecue-seasoned fries. It used to be an off-menu special in Pullman.
- Wagyu dogs. Original, BBQ and Chicago-style.
- Lighter options. A salmon burger and a chopped salad.
Eater Chicago added brisket baked beans and loaded mac and cheese to the list of Lexington Betty favorites making the trip, and called the menu quick, on-the-go lunch.
Its Clock Is the Campus Clock
The food-hall setting decides when you can eat there. For the week of Oct. 25, UChicago Dining's schedule had Hutchinson Commons open on these days:
| Day | Hutchinson Commons hours, week of Oct. 25, 2026 |
|---|---|
| Monday through Thursday | 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. |
| Friday | 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. |
| Saturday | 11 a.m. to 4 p.m. |
| Sunday | Closed |
Those are the hours for the whole hall. UChicago says campus dining runs standard hours while classes are in session during the regular quarter, and some locations close for holidays, breaks and summer. If you're planning a late-November or December visit, check the weekly schedule first, because Thanksgiving week and winter break both fall in that stretch.
Leach told FoodService Director that the school setting pushes her back toward a Monday-through-Friday rhythm, and that she likes the structure. She also expects to see more than 1,000 students come through the dining hall each day. For a neighbor, that makes Little Betty a weekday lunch or an early dinner. A Friday dinner is out, since the hall closes at 3 p.m., and so is a Sunday plate.
The Second Arrival Is Built for the Hours the First One Isn't
Sanders BBQ Prime fills the hours Little Betty misses. Sanders and his partner Ogbonna Bowden are taking the ground floor below the former Promontory, a longtime music venue that closed last year. They have worked on the project for well over a year. Sanders told the Herald that renovations are on schedule and the countertops are already in.
Sanders described these plans to the Herald:
- Seating. About 130 people, mostly at tables, with a large bar and an open kitchen. Sanders said some counter service will remain.
- Food. Shareable small bites such as smoked pimento cheese, beef tallow and smoked popcorn, plus grilled prawns, shrimp and oysters. "We're trying to honestly touch every aspect of barbecue or grilling that we can do," Sanders told the Herald.
- Drinks. Craft cocktails, including a Bloody Mary made with a bit of barbecue sauce, along with wine, beer and nonalcoholic options.
- Weeknights. Happy hour specials on food and drinks during the week.
- Sports. TVs showing games, because Sanders noticed a shortage of sports bars in Hyde Park.
Sanders also said he plans to hire 20 to 25 people, and wants a larger staff because of the restaurant's long hours.
The Beverly original sets the bar. Sanders BBQ Supply Co., at 1742 W. 99th St., opened in 2024 as a counter-service spot. It made The New York Times' 2025 restaurant list and was a 2026 James Beard Award semifinalist. Sanders said his goal there was to avoid running a typical Chicago smokehouse, so he picks a specific hardwood for each meat, uses prime-grade beef, and cooks regional styles from Texas to the Carolinas. Besides the long barbecue gap, he named the nearby Obama Presidential Center as part of the reason he chose Hyde Park.
Side by side, here is how the two compare:
| Little Betty Smokehouse | Sanders BBQ Prime | |
|---|---|---|
| Location | Hutchinson Commons, Reynolds Club, 5706 S. University Ave. | 5311 S. Lake Park Ave., below the former Promontory |
| Parent restaurant | Lexington Betty Smokehouse, Pullman | Sanders BBQ Supply Co., Beverly |
| Format | Food-hall counter, kiosk ordering, Grubhub pickup | Mostly sit-down, about 130 seats, large bar, open kitchen |
| Built around | Quick lunch on the academic calendar | Long hours, weekday happy hour, sports on TV |
| Status this fall | Open since late September | Friends-and-family preview planned for late November, grand opening expected in December |
Harper Court Got Its Cocktail Room First
Sanders BBQ Prime is not the only new evening spot this fall. On Friday, Oct. 23, Ald. Lamont Robinson (4th) joined owner Vince Tian and local business leaders to cut the ribbon at Mi Mi Dao, 1516 E. Harper Ct. The name means "secret island" in Mandarin. The menu draws on Chinese, Japanese and Thai flavors in shareable dishes, with specialty cocktails that include several tiki-inspired drinks.
Tian's partners, Pattie and Tom Kidwell, also own Chant and Noodles Etc. in the neighborhood. The Herald reported that the group first thought about a hot pot restaurant for the former Jade Court space before choosing modern Asian food with a full cocktail program. "Let's do something new over here," Tian said. The owners hope the restaurant brings more foot traffic to Harper Court.
Mi Mi Dao and Sanders BBQ Prime are each betting on evenings with a full bar, on Harper Court and on Lake Park Avenue a few blocks apart. Little Betty covers the middle of the day on campus.
The Weeks Between Now and December
Right now, Hyde Park has one of the two barbecue options. Little Betty is serving on weekdays and Saturdays, on whatever schedule Hutchinson Commons posts that week. Mi Mi Dao is open on Harper Court.
At 5311 S. Lake Park Ave., the friends-and-family preview is planned for late November, followed by a grand opening expected in December. Block Club Chicago reported on Sept. 29 that the target was opening by year's end, and the Herald's update in mid-October gave the same timeline.
If you want to try both before the year ends, plan around the calendar. Little Betty is easiest on a weekday before Thanksgiving week, while the quarter is in session and the Commons keeps its regular hours. Sanders BBQ Prime belongs to December, when the Lake Park Avenue room is expected to open to the public.
I grew up in the western suburbs, and I still pay attention when a South Side neighborhood gets a new place to gather. If you're thinking about how a neighborhood's restaurants and daily routines fit into your own plans for the city, Nina Trivedi is glad to talk it through. Start the Conversation.